First off, I'll begin with saying that I love the site and never want to leave it unless something truly bad happened. That doesn't mean it is without its share of problems I've noticed since I've joined.
1. It's rather limited in what is posted. I've seen a lot of threads go up, merely to be shut down from lack of interest. And I know that a lot of threads receive plenty of views, but views don't mean jack squat if no one else posts. Remember, views are only just a number, nothing more.
2. It's touchy. Now yes, I do know that this is the internet and occasionally messages come across wrong, it happens. However, it seems like in some cases, one person (seemingly on) purpose reacts to how another posts in a negative manner. Sometimes it is truly a misunderstanding, but in other cases, it's a major conflict of opinion, and neither member will back down.
3. Me. Don't start sayin that ain't true folks, because it is. You know it, I know, everyone else knows, at least to a limited degree. I truly bet there isn't a single post of mine that hasn't bugged at least one person. I honestly try and be modest about everything, as well as very carefully wording my posts when I make jokes/puns/references/etc; it doesn't allows work as you all know. I may be a goof folks, but I have a lot to think about before I make a post. I have to say it isn't truly as easy as it seems to be (and I don't say that to get pity from anyone). I have to remember I'm dealing with people from all over the world, some of whom aren't familar with "Western" customs and popular things. I also take into consideration other common viewpoints people have, like religious views and politics. Honestly, if you were to look through all of my posts, you would not see one "definite" joke about a religion, among other things people highly believe in. I also almost never post negatively about anything, aka, 'posting just to say I don't like it.' I see that fairly often.
4. Some lack of net etiquette. I notice people aren't exactly following the "rules" all the time. Mostly in two cases. One, people requesting, alot, and often. It seems to happen everywhere someone puts up a thread for requests (except mine, unsurprisingly). Heaps of requests, with barely a thanks after even one is done, which they which they follow with many more requests. I'm sure you can guess the members who I'm mainly refering to, correct? Two, members who "threadromancy." In other words, a person who revives an old thread, long after it "died." This is mostly annoying to those who are simply viewing the forum (especially members who have been there a long time) and suddenly see an ancient thread with a new post. Very rarely, this is an ok thing, and the thread revives without much fuss, basically it returns to how it was, maybe even better. The worst kind is a thread that was the site of a flame war (or at least a heated argument). Because usually that brings up old ill will in people, especially in the posters in said "war."
5. Stories and critiques. I don't mean any content of stories there for starters, once again going back to negative posting. But what I mean is when a person makes a bit of a "critique" for a writer, but in said critique, they make "suggestions" that basically fulfill their fantasies, not what the writer wants. Sometimes this can also include negative posting as well. Also, as a purely personal feeling, I believe that all critiques and help for others should only come from those who already know how to do it. Like I am one of two video morphers left (though I'm no where NEAR O's level), so I'm rather willing to help out new morphers. I really want to pass on my knowledge (so far, to no avail), to help keep video morphing alive (it's been around for awhile people) in the face of better looking still-picture morphs and 3d stuff. It's not nearly as good, but some of the first "real" muscle growth I ever saw here on the web was the old site, musclemorphs.com (which is long since gone, never to return).
This post was pretty blunt, but this is my SS, so you can still expect more of it of course.